I played this in high school at my lunch table.
Someone holds the pencil, point up.
Another person has an apple. Fujis work well.
The person with the apple attempts to lob the apple into the air such that it lands on the pencil and sticks. If they succeed, they win, and the pencil-holder eats the apple (but not of course the pencil).
If they fail, the pencil-holder hands the pencil to someone else and play continues until there is a winner.